“Forgive me, I must start by pointing out that three years after a horrific financial crisis caused by massive fraud, not a single financial executive has gone to jail and that’s wrong.”
For me, this quip from Charles Ferguson, director of “Inside Job,” which won for Best Documentary Film, was the best acceptance speech from the recent Academy Awards.
Bankers, predatory lenders, mortgage services, robo-signers have yet to be held accountable for the criminal practices they have wreaked on homeowners who were the victims of fraud during the mortgage meltdown.
Study after study and expert after expert has shown that the banking industry abandoned its own lending standards to ensure there were enough mortgages to fuel the insatiable securitization machine. They then turned the mortgage securities into CDO’s and CDO-squareds and credit default swaps, which multiplied the damage exponentially.
Banks knew most of these loans would default, but they sold them to pension funds (you and me) anyway, as AAA-rated investments. Homeowners were mere instrumentalities in the mortgage fraud, which have been perpetrated literally millions of times.
Think about these numbers: In normal times, banks foreclose on approximately 100,000 homes annually, but from January through September 2010, almost 2.7 million homeowners received foreclosure notices. September alone saw more than 100,000 bank repossessions. According to the Special Inspector General for the Troubled Asset Relief Program, foreclosure notices will have been sent to more than 3.5 million homes by year end 2010.
So, is there a solution to this mess? Well, while we’re still waiting for our illustrious state legislators to wake up to the national tragedy of the foreclosure crisis, and still waiting for our Attorneys General to prosecute these financial executives, Georgetown University law Professor Adam Levitin has proposed a solution called Chapter M for mortgage bankruptcy.
Many industry experts are calling Professor Levitin’s Chapter M as “the easiest and most efficient way to solve the crisis in the housing market.
The key point to Chapter M is that it would remove foreclosure actions from state courts to federal bankruptcy courts under standardized, streamline procedures.
Here’s how it would work:
- Homeowner must document the ability to pay, and the lender must document the title to the note and mortgage, but with validity of securitization transfers conclusively presumed.
- If the homeowner is willing and able to pay, then the homeowner keeps the house. A fresh appraisal is done by a court-appointed appraiser. If the homeowner re-defaults, the foreclosure process can speed up. It wouldn’t affect non-mortgage lenders. It is fast-tracked relative to traditional Chapter 13.
- The Lender may choose between an FHA short-refi with principal reduced to [90]% of LTV or a standardized loan modification with principal reduced to 100% LTV and loan restructured to 30-year fixed-rate, full amortization, market interest rate adjusted to ensure maximum [31]% DTI ratio), with 50% risk-weighting for modified loans.
- If the homeowner does not qualify, the lender gets same fast-tracked federal foreclosure and quiet title coming out of the foreclosure sale. If the lender cannot show title, then the homeowner gets quiet title to property. In all situations, the homeowner’s non-mortgage debts “ride-thru” the Chapter M bankruptcy, unaffected, but the homeowner could also file for a traditional Chapter 7 or 13 bankruptcy to address those debts.
- Is Chapter M a viable solution to the mortgage crisis? Yes! It has no cost to the federal government. It builds off existing infrastructure, and can be started immediately using existing bankruptcy courts and Chapter 7 panel trustees for sales.
We have to start cleaning up this mess. Now.